Gaetano Ciccarelli first appears in the Painesville, Ohio, area in 1913.
Gaetano Ciccarelli, son of Salvatore Ciccarelli, was born about 1897, at Montemaggiore Belsito, Sicily. Gaetano Ciccarelli immigrated to the United States on April 5, 1913. He was travelling to Painesville, Ohio to join his cousin, Liborio Catalano.
Gaetano probably left Painesville before 1917.
How Gaetano Ciccarelli was related to Ignazio Ciccarelli, or Antonio Ciccarello and his son, Stefano, is not known.